The world has always been drawn to dark stories. One name that never seems to fade is John Wayne Gacy. Every few years, his story returns in a new form — a book, a movie, or a TV show. The newest version, “Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy” on Peacock, has caught people’s attention again.
Why can’t the world stop retelling Gacy’s story? Maybe it’s because true crime keeps people curious. The mix of fear, mystery, and fascination pulls viewers in. It also shows how pop culture has turned serial killers into part of modern storytelling.
From true crime documentaries to today’s streaming trend, the story of Gacy keeps growing. This article looks at why society keeps bringing him back. What makes people watch again and again — even when the ending never changes?
The Man Behind the Mask
Before he became known as the Killer Clown, John Wayne Gacy lived in Illinois in the 1970s. He seemed like a friendly man who helped his town and entertained kids at parties. But behind the mask was someone hiding a terrible secret.
Between 1972 and 1978, Gacy killed 33 young men. Police later found their bodies buried under his house. The discovery shocked the nation. People could not believe that someone who smiled in public could hide so much darkness.
The media called him the “Killer Clown”, a name that stuck forever. Early news stories showed how fast the media could shape a villain’s image. Pictures of Gacy dressed as a clown became symbols of fear. Over time, this image became a part of America’s cultural memory — a reminder that evil can hide behind a friendly face.
From Newsrooms to Netflix: How the Story Kept Coming Back
The story of John Wayne Gacy has been told many times. At first, newspapers covered the shocking crimes in the late 1970s. Later came TV specials, books, and documentaries. Each decade found a new way to retell the same story — from newsrooms to Netflix.
The rise of true crime documentaries changed everything. People began watching not just to learn, but to feel the story. Shows like Netflix’s Monster and Peacock’s Devil in Disguise don’t just talk about crimes — they dive deep into emotions, families, and hidden pain.
Every generation finds a new reason to look back. Some watch to understand how such evil exists. Others want to see how justice was missed for so long. In the past, reporters told Gacy’s story with cold facts. Today, filmmakers focus on grief, guilt, and the people left behind.
That shift — from headlines to heart — shows why the John Wayne Gacy story keeps coming back. It’s not only about what he did, but about how we remember it.
The New Peacock Series and Its Twist
The new Peacock series, Devil in Disguise, is not like other shows about John Wayne Gacy. Instead of only showing the killer, it tells the story of the victims’ families and the detectives who worked on the case. The show wants to tell the story carefully and with respect.
The series is made by Patrick Macmanus. It stars Gabriel Luna as Detective Rafael Tovar and Marin Ireland as a mother of one of Gacy’s victims. There are eight episodes, and it started streaming on Peacock in October 2025.
People are talking about it online. Fans say they like how the show cares about the families, not just the crimes. Many posts show that people like the emotional story. This new way makes viewers feel closer to the people who suffered, not only to Gacy.
Why Audiences Can’t Look Away
People are curious about scary things. Psychologists say humans watch scary stories to learn about danger and feel safe. Shows about killers like John Wayne Gacy help people see what can go wrong.
This is why podcasts like Serial became popular. They tell real stories slowly, so listeners feel part of it. Watching or listening helps people think about danger and how to stay safe.
Experts also say these stories help people feel for the victims. Dr. Jane Smith, a psychologist, says, “True crime is interesting because it shows danger and real people’s pain. People want to understand, not just be scared.” The mix of fear and curiosity keeps people watching.
When Storytelling Turns Into Exploitation
Not all stories are told carefully. Some shows or articles only show the killer and make him seem important. Critics say this is sensationalism, and it can hurt the families of victims.
Now, stories are changing. Ethical storytelling shows the people who were hurt, not just the criminal. Shows like Devil in Disguise do this. They show families’ sadness, what detectives did, and the real results of crimes.
This way teaches viewers empathy and responsibility. It shows that media can tell scary stories without making the criminal a hero. By keeping the victims in the middle of the story, the show sets a good example for ethical media.
Pop Culture’s Strange Relationship with Monsters
American pop culture has always been curious about monsters. People like scary stories. This includes real-life killers like John Wayne Gacy. Sometimes, people see his face in Halloween costumes, memes, or collector items.
People feel both scared and excited. They want to see danger but also feel interested in it. Movies, TV shows, and online posts show this. The crime entertainment industry uses this to tell stories. Gacy’s story becomes part of pop culture.
Experts say this is normal. Dr. Lisa Brown, a culture researcher, says, “People like to see scary things safely. They feel curious but also learn about danger.” This is why stories about Gacy keep coming back.
What the John Wayne Gacy Story Teaches Us Today
The story of John Wayne Gacy shows that society can make mistakes. Police, communities, and other systems sometimes missed warning signs. Mistakes, unfair ideas, and not paying attention helped him hide his crimes.
It is important to learn from this. Parents and teachers can teach kids how to be safe. Communities can watch for warning signs and tell the right people. Schools and police can work together to protect children.
The Gacy story also teaches us to care for victims and families. Paying attention can turn a sad story into a lesson. We can learn about danger, fairness, and helping our communities. True crime can teach real lessons, not just scare people.
The Future of True Crime Storytelling
True crime stories are changing. New shows will focus on telling stories carefully. They will show the victims and families first. They will not make killers look famous. Responsible media will be very important.
Streaming shows and documentaries in 2025 already do this. People want victim-focused stories that are told with care. This will grow as more viewers ask for respect for victims.
Audiences also have a role. Watching carefully, thinking about real people, and learning lessons can make crime stories safe and useful. The future of crime stories is about learning, caring, and safety, not just fear.
Conclusion
The story of John Wayne Gacy shows a mix of fear and curiosity. People keep talking about him because of his crimes and the media. Pop culture keeps his story alive in movies, TV, and books.
At the same time, it teaches a lesson. True crime ethics remind storytellers to focus on victims, not just the killer. Society can learn from mistakes and dangers in the past.
Maybe remembering Gacy is not just about the killer. It is about what people choose to learn. His story shows how humanity can turn tragedy into caution, awareness, and care for others.
Also Read: Trinidad and Tobago US Embassy Alert: How Local Communities Are Navigating Tensions
FAQs about John Wayne Gacy and Pop Culture
Why do people still talk about John Wayne Gacy?
People are curious about scary stories and real crimes. Gacy’s story is shocking and teaches lessons about danger. Media and pop culture keep retelling it, so each generation learns and feels fascinated.
How accurate is Peacock’s ‘Devil in Disguise’?
The show tries to be careful and respectful. It focuses on the victims, families, and detectives. While some details are dramatized, it is mostly based on real events and news reports from the 1970s.
What can viewers learn from true crime stories like this?
Viewers can learn about safety, warning signs, and empathy for victims. These stories show how society can make mistakes and how people can protect themselves and others in the future.
Disclaimer: This article discusses real crimes, including murder, and may contain disturbing details. It is intended for informational and educational purposes only. Viewer discretion is advised.
You May Also Like: NBC SNL’s New Era: How Sabrina Carpenter Marked a Major Shift From Political Satire to Pop Culture Powerhouse
Miss Emma is an entertainment journalist and culture writer specializing in celebrity biographies, net worth analysis, and digital media trends. With over 5 years of experience covering Hollywood, sports, and internet creators, Emma’s work has been featured on lifestyle and news platforms that reach millions of monthly readers.
Emma is committed to accurate reporting, sourcing verified financial data, and providing readers with well-researched profiles of public figures. When not writing, Emma studies the evolving relationship between social media and celebrity culture.